Brazil, review

State of Wonder by Ann Patchett

state of wonderState of Wonder by Ann Patchett

Harper Perennial, 2011

I finally dusted State of Wonder off my shelf because I picked it for book club. I really liked Bel Canto and thought the same sort of novel would make for a good discussion and for a non-annoying read. After finishing SoW, I still prefer Bel Canto, and I think it’s because the form of the novel felt unsatisfying to me.

First of all, all I really knew about the book going in was that it was a sort of female version of Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad. State of Wonder is much longer, with lots of descriptions of every step before the journey up the river into the rainforest. Conrad’s story is much, much leaner. Both stories have a sort of a cipher of a narrator (or I may just not remember much about the protagonist of the book I read last as a teenager). Marina Singh is an MD turned pharmacologist working in Minnesota for a pharmaceutical company funding the fertility drug research of Dr. Swenson, one of the ob/gyns who trained her over a decade before the story takes place. Marina’s officemate Dr. Eckman is sent to the Amazon to check up on Dr. Swenson, and after word arrives that he’s died, Marina travels to find out what happened to him. After a long and strange interlude in the city of Manaus, Marina leaves for the lab and camp in the jungle, and that’s my favorite third of the book. Everything else leads up to the journey.

I ultimately felt unsatisfied because the book felt like a retake of Orpheus and Eurydice with the woman doing the rescuing. It doesn’t feel like a complete tale though the endings are different. My favorite version of Orpheus and Eurydice is a play, Eurydice by Sarah Ruhl, which is a version of the myth from Eurydice’s perspective. It was stranger and more emotional somehow. Marina is a very closed-off person, and even throwing in her relationship with a young deaf boy in the jungle doesn’t humanize her much, and it feels like a bit of an old trick a la the movie Aliens.

 

Patchett writes beautifully, but ultimately I was not that interested in long descriptions of the jungle or the odd city of Manaus and it’s gorgeous opera-house. And I didn’t find the story of what was going on with Dr. Swenson’s research that enthralling because the characters were so closed-off. You know when you think a book is more focused on an idea than on a story? That’s this book.

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “State of Wonder by Ann Patchett”

  1. I’ve actually got this one on my TBR list because I was an anthropologist and almost ended up doing some research at the University of Manaus. Besides, I like the name of the protagonist 😉

    1. Of course, great name! I read that she was trying to pay homage to Henry James’s The Ambassadors, which is probably why I had a difficult time with it. If you like James, this may be up your alley.

  2. I wasn’t thrilled by this one either. It took so long to get going and I found the ending terrible – she made everyone act so out of character it crossed the credibility line by miles… I haven’t read Bel Canto, though everyone seems to think it’s better. This one kind of put me off her.

  3. Friends loved Bel Canto, the writing more than anything. I liked State of Wonder, not loved. I thought too much detail in the earlier part of the book and not enough going on.
    I did like the ethical dilemmas the writer puts at the end of the book. Whose life has value? Are some lives valued more than others? If so, why? Is it reasonable?
    The ending made me angry, the attitude behind it. I’m sure I wasn’t alone in my views.
    But it is thought-provoking, and it’s also about who has power and who doesn’t.

    I want to read Bel Canto, must do so next year.

    1. I hope you like Bel Canto, Kathy. As for SOW, I wasn’t a fan of the ending as well, and it was just another part of the character of Marina that alienated me from her. I read that SOW is an homage to Henry James’s The Ambassadors, and since I tend to have a difficult time getting into Henry James, I think I know why this book bothered me.I kept hoping for more Dr. Swenson scenes instead.

  4. Yes! More Dr. Swenson scenes. I hadn’t thought of that, but it’s true.
    Too much boring stuff with Marina on her travails in getting to Dr. Swenson’s location.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s