The Good Suicides by Antonio Hill

good suicidesThe Good Suicides by Antonio Hill, translated by Laura McGloughlin
Crown, June 2014
Inspector Salgado  book 2
Disclosure: I received a review copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Héctor Salgado  is a police inspector from Argentina who lives and works in Barcelona, and this particular novel takes place six months after the disappearance of his estranged wife Ruth and the end of a particularly violent case that was featured in the first novel, The Summer of Dead Toys. Besides the case of Salgado’s wife’s disappearance, the novel focuses on the apparent suicides of several people who work for Alemany Cosmetics. That investigation slows the book down, I think, and I think it comes down to the fact that I didn’t particularly feel invested in their stories.

My copy of the novel calls it a thriller, but only the first and last sections of the book feel thriller-esque in terms of pacing and reveals. I’m not sure what the marketing or book-cataloging logic was for calling this a thriller: police procedural is not so catchy, perhaps.  It’s a good police procedural, with the caveat that the Alemany Cosmetics investigation led by Salgado is just part of the story. The other and stronger part of the book is Leire Castro’s unofficial investigation into Ruth’s disappearance. Castro is an interesting character: she is a young, female detective young and about to give birth. She stands in contrast to the divorced and depressed Salgado, and what she eventually uncovers makes the story very powerful.

I was a very big fan of the first book in this series, The Summer of Dead Toys, and this book, the second in a proposed trilogy, was a solid entry but not as outstanding as the first novel.

Other reviews appear in EuroCrime (Laura), The Game’s Afoot (Jose Ignacio), and crimepieces (Sarah).

9 thoughts on “The Good Suicides by Antonio Hill

  1. Rebecca – I wondered if this would be as good as The Summer of Dead Toys. And you touch on something that’s so important. Without feeling invested in characters, it’s hard to stay ‘into’ the story. Thanks for the well-written review.

    • Thanks for stopping by, Margot. Like I just commented above, I’m invested enough into the missing-wife storyline to get to book 3 🙂

  2. Huh, this review made me want to read The Summer of Dead Toys. I think I was on the fence with that one. At any rate, I’ll keep a look-out for this series.

    • Hope you like it when you get to it, Keishon. I think his job translating crime novels from English to Spanish was a huge help when he wrote his first book.

  3. I will try The Summer of Dead Toys and then decide whether to proceed to this one. I am interested in more books set in South American countries. I am going to have to clone myself to read all the book I want to read.

  4. Clone ourselves, campaign for a 30-hour day, an 8-day week, paid “reading” days, a reading vacation, or learn to live without sleep (except for parents of young children who need all the sleep they can get!) or read while doing tasks, etc.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s